01
What it is
Bore scoring is wear damage to the cylinder wall and the piston skirt.[1] Both engine builders describe the same starting point: the coating on the piston skirt fails, and aluminium then runs on aluminium.[1][3]
It usually starts on one bank. Two builders name bank 2, one of them cylinders 4 to 6 with cylinder 6 often first; on the 911, bank 2 is on the right. A press test names the right-hand bank with a sooty left tailpipe.[3][8][5]
No fleet-wide failure rate is published. A 2015 magazine article quotes three UK workshops: about 1 % of 1,500 cars inspected at one, about 2.5 % of the 3.6 and 3.8 engines seen at another, and 0.2 % at a third. The samples differ and are not a rate for all cars.[7]
02
How to recognise it
Three signs are named by two sources each: rising oil consumption, a ticking or tapping noise from piston slap that is often taken for lifter noise, and one tailpipe sootier than the other.[1][2][5]
None of these proves scoring on its own.[2]
03
How it is checked
A borescope look at the cylinder walls is the most direct confirmation.[1][2] Oil analysis alone does not confirm scoring.[1][2]
Two sources add that compression and leak-down tests can stay normal in early scoring.[1][19]
04
What it costs to fix
Two sources say oil, additives or a flush do not reverse scoring; the lasting fix means taking the engine apart.[1][20] One builder says early cases can sometimes be saved without a full rebuild.[18] Both builders name the same lasting repair: the bore surface is replaced with Nikasil-plated aluminium cylinders.[1][3]
Sources disagree on boring to oversize with matching pistons. Hartech reported that it did not last, but its later interim engine guide calls its most recent versions reliable; Cartronic expects repeat damage on re-bored cylinders.[3][25][24]